logo_prisma
Joanne Kathleen Rowling

Joanne Kathleen Rowling

The British author best known for her wildly popular Harry Potter series, Joanne Kathleen Rowling or J.K. Rowling has faced public backlash on multiple occasions. Her controversial statements on social media and in interviews have led to accusations of transphobia, and other forms of discrimination. Below, we have compiled some of J.K. Rowling's public criticisms.

photo 1/20 © Dave J Hogan

Support for Maya Forstater

Support for Maya Forstater

Rowling was criticised for her support of Maya Forstater, a researcher who had been fired for her views on transgender rights. Many saw Rowling's support as an endorsement of transphobic views.

photo 3/20 © Bertrand Rindoff Petroff

Defending Johnny Depp’s casting

Defending Johnny Depp’s casting

The "Harry Potter" author faced backlash for defending Johnny Depp's casting in "Fantastic Beasts" despite domestic abuse allegations. The choice of Depp in the movie has drawn the attention of the public so his role in the upcoming sequel has been recast due to fan petitions.

photo 4/20 © Dave J Hogan 

A controversial essay

A controversial essay

In a blog post entitled “J.K. Rowling Writes about Her Reasons for Speaking out on Sex and Gender Issues”, Rowling responded to the backlash by writing a lengthy essay about her views on gender identity, leading to further criticism.

photo 6/20 © Walter McBride

Harry Potter’s cast members responded

Harry Potter’s cast members responded

Some of the Harry Potter cast members, including Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson, and Rupert Grint, publicly spoke out against Rowling's comments and showed their support for the transgender community.

photo 7/20 © Dave M. Benett 

Her latest novel faced criticism

Her latest novel faced criticism

Released in September 2020, J.K. Rowling's novel “Troubled Blood” published under the pseudonym Robert Galbraith also faced criticism for her portrayal of a cross-dressing serial killer. The book was deemed offensive and triggering by some readers, leading to calls for boycotts and the cancellation of the book.

photo 10/20 © Samir Hussein

The stereotyped magical creatures

The stereotyped magical creatures

Her use of harmful stereotypes in the portrayal of goblins and other magical creatures in the Harry Potter series has also been condemned. Actually, she was accused of including anti-Semitic stereotypes. The descriptions of the goblins in the series bear a striking resemblance to anti-Semitic stereotypes.

photo 13/20 © Luca Teuchmann 

Her works raised questions about religion

Her works raised questions about religion

Some have criticised her for the way she handles religion in the series, accusing her of promoting a narrow view of Christianity. They accused the Harry Potter series of depicting evil and encouraging occultism.

photo 16/20 © Anwar Hussein Collection/ROTA

Against the Scottish government's gender legislation

Against the Scottish government's gender legislation

In October 2022, J.K. Rowling declared her support for demonstrations against the Scottish gender legislation, which intends to facilitate lawful recognition of individuals as their desired sex.

photo 17/20 © Dave M. Benett

J.K. Rowling speaks out on hormone therapy

J.K. Rowling speaks out on hormone therapy

The 57-year-old writer caused controversy when she liked a tweet declaring that hormone prescriptions are the new antidepressants. Many Twitter users viewed this as an assumption that trans people are mentally unwell as well as an insinuation that those who take anti-depressants are lazy.

photo 18/20 © Fred Duval 

Her comments on “People who menstruate”

Her comments on “People who menstruate”

J.K. Rowling tweeted in response to a comment about how the post how COVID-19 was affecting women who have periods. The post mocked trans people by suggesting that period-free women are not real women.

photo 19/20 © David Levenson

J.K. Rowling missing in the Harry Potter 20th anniversary

J.K. Rowling missing in the Harry Potter 20th anniversary

The author was notably absent from HBO Max's Harry Potter 20th Anniversary: Return To Hogwarts special, which gathers cast members and some film directors. However, she explained that she refused an invitation to be included in the special.

photo 20/20 © Fred Duval 

A voir aussi